What Are The Particular Psychological Problems Faced By Veterans, And How Can They Be Addressed?
Updated: Nov 2
It is indeed a fact, that military veterans run a higher likelihood of an exposure, or multiple exposures to traumatic events. These events may have a lasting and drastic effect upon a veteran’s state of mind, and many have attributed the psychological disorders, neurosis and struggles that they face on the events that they faced within military service. Rates of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD), addiction, risk taking behaviours, depression, anxiety, violence and other mental health disorders are statistically higher in veterans than in other civilian demographics. In this essay, we will explore those exposures and why many individuals may struggle post service, once transitioned from serving soldier, into civilian life. We will look firstly at the types of exposures, the severity of those exposures, then the risk factors affecting veterans specifically, the treatment and processes that they can receive, or not, as the case may be. I will also explore why veterans might not be receiving this essential post – service care; from the culture within the veteran community, to the failings within the health care system, from the attitudes, behaviours and beliefs of the individual to a deep-rooted distrust of the very system designed to serve them, this focus will be entirely on veterans of the British Forces.
To begin, we must define exactly what constitutes a veteran, according to official UK government guidelines, a veteran is described as “anyone who has served for at least one day in Her Majesty’s Armed Forces (Regular or Reserve).”[1] Of which there are 2.4 million veterans currently residing in the UK, constituting approximately 5% of the population [2]. This in itself, reveals a very interesting challenge already, that only 5% of the population, consists of veterans spread across the UK, that the tiny percentage of the population that has served, may lead to an increased sense of isolation and lack of identity within the veteran community. If we are to consider the lifestyle of their service, before leaving the Armed Forces, most would have served in a Regiment, Squadron or Unit that provided them with that identity of camaraderie. The opening line of the recruit application website of the British Army is “Become the best. Whatever you choose. Find where you belong.”[3] This language shows how the military has focused on recruiting individuals seeking a sense of identity, which they may well lose, as they transition from being in a unit with a esprit de corps and purpose, to being part of the 5%, adding to the burden of psychological problems, faced by the veteran community, isolation and a lack of purpose. It is also worth noting that many individual veterans may find themselves isolated because of so few units recruiting from a specific area, with Regiments with a specific Country within their military title may still recruit from across the UK, and not a single Regiment recruiting from a single county anymore[4]. This makes the veteran potentially geographically isolated, if, for example, they were recruited to a national recruitment regiment, such as the Parachute Regiment, and returned to their hometown, it could be fair to assume that they were geographically isolated from anyone else who had served within the same Regiment, adding to the sense of isolation.
We must examine the diagnosis rates within veterans and exactly what those diagnoses are and how they compare to civilian counterparts. “ 2449 veteran PHC records were analysed. 38% (N=938) of veterans in this cohort had a code on their medical record for common mental health disorders. The highest disorder prevalence was depression (17.8%, N=437), followed by alcohol misuse (17.3%, N=423) and anxiety (15.0%, N=367). Lower disorder prevalence was seen across post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) (3.4%, N=83), dementia (1.8%, N=45) and substance misuse (0.8%, N=19). Female veterans had a higher prevalence of mental disorders than their male counterparts, while men a higher prevalence of PTSD; however, the gender difference in the latter was not significant (p>0.05).”[5] This shows, how there is a wide variety of diagnoses that veterans may face, along with a divide between the male and female.
We must explore how this differs with the civilian population “Male veterans were more likely to report probable mental health problems than male non-veterans of the same age, but there was no significant difference between female veterans and female non-veterans of the same age.” [6] So male veterans were more likely to struggle with their mental health than their civilian counterparts.
If we consider the austere environments and situations recently deployed troops of the UK Armed Forces would have experienced, it is not surprising that they may have experienced traumatic events. In fact, we would only need to examine deployments from 2010-2020; “2010 Operation Herrick(Afghanistan) , 2011 Operation Ellamy (Libya), 2012 Operation Olympics (London), 2013 Operation Patwin (Philippines), 2014 Operation Gritlock (Sierra Leone), 2014 Operation Shader (Iraq and Syria), 2015 Operation Toral (Afghanistan), 2015 Operation Orbital (Ukraine), 2016 Antarctic Patrol (Antarctic), 2017 Operation Trenton (South Sudan), 2017 Operation Temperer (UK various), 2017 Operation Ruman (Caribbean), 2018 Operation Newcombe (Mali), 2019 Operation Barytone (Caribbean), with over 11,000 personnel currently deployed overseas.”[7] This highlights that service men and women will have had exposures that their civilian counterparts will not have had, and that may well, go some distance into explaining why they may struggle once leaving the armed forces and the particular psychological problems that they face. If we are to examine the first point, that only 5% of the population is a veteran, which actually covers a very broad sense of the word, with some only having served a single day and some in excess of 30 years, separated not just numerically, but also geographically, isolated and now with experiences that they simply will not be able to share with the civilian population, that as a veteran they now find themselves within. This lack of identity, isolation and inability to bond with a peer group with little shared experiences can exacerbate the psychological problems facing veterans.
We must now examine the culture within the veteran community and why these may well present their own difficulties and particular psychological challenges. “A number of barriers and facilitators of help-seeking for a mental health issue within the veteran population were identified. Barriers included stigma, military culture of stoicism and self-reliance, as well as deployment characteristics of combat exposure and different warzone deployments. Health service difficulties such as access and lack of understanding by civilian staff were also identified.” [8]
But why do veterans face these very specific problems and how can we negate against them? First issue identified is the stigma attached to seeking help for a mental health issue. To understand stigma, we must consider it from 3 different angles, public, internalised, structural stigma “Common types of perceived stigma include public stigma, internalised stigma and structural discrimination. Public stigma, where others endorse prejudice against those with mental health problems, in an Armed Forces (AF) context can relate to concerns of being perceived as less competent by colleagues or experiencing differential treatment by unit leaders. On the other hand, internalised stigma occurs when an individual with mental health difficulties internalises negative stereotypes held by society resulting in poorer self-esteem and feelings of shame. In an AF context, commonly described internalised stigma beliefs include ‘I am weak’ and ‘I am crazy’. Finally, structural discrimination can be experienced when an organisation’s regulations may (un)intentionally disadvantage those with mental health difficulties. Examples of structural discrimination can include perceived difficulty taking time off work for an appointment or a lack of resources to access help.”[9] As a veteran, who served 14 years in the regular army and now serving within the reserves, I do not find these results particularly shocking. I understand the stigma entirely, that may well carry over into civilian life. The belief that one must remain stoic and controlled, is absolutely instilled in young recruits and is used as a training point for young members of the Airborne Forces, who must memorise a speech made by the airborne Forces by Field Marshal Montgomery in which he describes the Airborne; “They are, in fact, men apart – every man an Emperor.[10]” Which is part of the Parachute Regiment Charter, along with “Through rigorous selection and hard training, the airborne soldier was expected “to develop a temper of mind that bred resilience, self-confidence and a fierce determination to succeed, whatever the difficulties. [11]“ This education into being completely self-reliant and very stoic, can easily be misconstrued as not wanting to receive help for any common mental health disorders that a veteran may face. The pride that a veteran had from their military service, upholding the values and standards of their subjective unit, can be misconstrued as an isolated and frustrated civilian.
The desire to not display mental health disorders for fear of reprisal from peers and colleagues, is a trait that we can also observe coming from military service, especially when we take a closer look at the military health care system and its treatment of the sick and wounded. There are varying degrees of deployability, how a serviceperson may be used, all affected by both physical and mental health “Service personnel with medical conditions or fitness issues which affect their ability to perform their duties are assessed in Primary Care or referred to a Medical Board for a medical examination and review of their medical grading. The patient may be downgraded to allow for treatment and rehabilitation.” [12] This inability to deploy, which includes operations, exercises or arduous courses, will often dissuade soldiers from reporting sick when suffering with their mental health, this can also be carried on, once transitioning has occurred into civilian life. The vast majority of service personnel will join the military because they want that sense of adventure, they want to experience the world and military service, to be unable to do so, because of injury, illness, psychological injury or other factors, will potentially dissuade an individual from presenting their health care concerns to a health care professional. As previously mentioned, the unity and identity that the UK Armed Forces provides, is absolutely essential to its appeal, to have joined and then miss the opportunity to enjoy that aspect of military life will play a role; particularly with young soldiers, joining at 16 years of age, serving 22 years, their entire understanding of behaviours has been framed by what they were taught in the military. The belief that they must remain stoic and an unwillingness to receive much needed treatment for their mental health, can be very much understood now that we can consider their environment and its attitude toward health care. Those same young men and women, with their desire to maintain a sense of Regimental/Squadron/Unit pride and not admit to when needing health care, especially that of psychological assistance, is what can make veterans so problematic to receiving the healthcare that they need.
A consideration must also be made, for the veteran’s deep distrust of the health care system, which is down to several factors. Firstly, we must examine the health inequality that many veterans would have witnessed as children “The Marmot review into health inequalities was published in 2010 – Fair Society, Healthier Lives noted that health inequalities were closely related to deprivation. “[13] Many soldiers are recruited from the low socio-economic backgrounds, and they will have witnessed the health inequality as children, which will only increase their prejudices against the system as adults. Another factor affecting this prejudice, is the, in my experience, fairly outlandish claims made by the veteran community in the health service that they may or may not have received. Although, there may indeed be some who have had a difficult process with their mental health requirements not being met, there is definitely a culture of resistance toward health services and distrust within the veteran community. Despite the fact that “Under the Armed Forces Covenant, you are entitled to priority treatment in the NHS for conditions linked to your military service.”[14] The armed forces covenant, is a very prominent step in the right direction for the relief of the perception of a health care disparity, and to reinstil a sense of trust and equality within the system itself. However, that attitude is a long way from being resolved.
Secondly, the poor attitude of veterans towards the health care system, can also be attributed to a difficulty in communication between veterans and their health care professionals, with NHS Suffolk having produced a comprehensive list of terminology used by British service personnel to assist their staff in communication with the attending veterans that they may encounter “The British army, like most armies around the world, have their own language which is often incomprehensible to many a civilian. The guide below should help you understand the commonly used words and phrases in the UK military:”[15] This highlights how difficult it can be for an individual with little, to no military service to communicate with a veteran. Considering that 95% of the population will not have had military service and therefore a very limited exposure to the language, terminology and mannerisms used. It is understandable that a veteran would struggle to be able to communicate their emotional needs to receive the appropriate psychological care required when they are using a language that they will have spoken since, for some at least, they were 16 years old.
It can also be identified that with the 5% of the population having had an experience of military service and the tendency for the military to recruit nationally rather than by county lines or cities or towns, that veteran’s ability to access veteran specific mental health services will have been greatly hindered. In an attempt to manage this, a new NHS initiative called Op Courage has been launched, “Everyone at Op COURAGE is either from the armed forces community or is experienced in working with serving personnel, reservists, veterans and their families…They understand military life and the courage it takes to speak with someone. They will work with you to make sure you get the right type of specialist care, support and treatment.”[16] This service can be accessed nationally through any of the local GPs that a veteran may be attending and is designed to ease the process of mental health delivery services for them having identified that the isolation and barriers to communication that exist are large factors towards the very particular psychological problems faced by veterans.
In conclusion, there are several factors affecting veterans and their particular psychological problems. A feeling of isolation, with only 5% of the population having served and being recruited nationally rather than by region means they often find themselves without the support recruited post-military service; an inability to effectively communicate with those health care professionals whose both language and experiences will be extremely far removed from the realities of military service and the diverse environments, stressors and exposures that it brings. Veterans that are unwilling to speak to health care professionals about their psychological need, because of a toxic culture towards mental health, perpetuated by their military service. A regimental ethos, motto and culture that can influence the decision to seek help negatively, but also, the treatment of those who are temporarily downgraded for their health, often means that service personnel are forced to miss out on opportunities that they otherwise would not have, this translates into civilian life as a lack of willingness to search for support. Finally, a deep distrust of the health care system, anecdotal evidence poorly disguised as factual information by senior members of the veteran communities on social media, and a distrust formed from early experiences of systematic failure for individuals from low socio-economic backgrounds, means that they are resistant to the urge to seek out their much-needed support.
Stronger, together.
James Elliott
Founder, Think Yourself Resilient
If you would like to talk about coaching or courses with Think Yourself Resilient, contact rachel@thinkyourselfresilient.co.uk
References
[1] Office for Veterans’ Affairs “Veterans Factsheet 2020” Page 2 “Definition”
[2] Ministry of Defence “Annual Population Survey: UK Armed Forces Veterans residing in Great Britain 2017” Page 1 “key points” Published 31 January 2019
[3] “Join the Army – Regiments of the British Army – https://apply.army.mod.uk/applynow (02 Apr 2022)
[4] Ministry of Defence “Information regarding the recruiting areas of each infantry battalion” Annex B to CHAPTER 12 (26 September 17)
[5] Alen Finegan and R Randles - “Prevalence of common mental health disorders in military veterans: using primary healthcare data” Page 1 “Result” (18 January 2022)
[6] Dr Rebecca Rhead Professor Nicola Fear Professor Neil Greenberg Dr Laura Goodwin Dr Deirdre MacManus “The mental health and treatment needs of UK ex-military personnel “ 1.1 “Findings From Study 1” (2018)
[7] Ministry of Defence - https://medium.com/voices-of-the-armed-forces/a-decade-of-deployments-2010-to-2020-ea4d2236da4c (published Jan 8th 2020)
[8] Randles R, Finnegan A “Veteran help-seeking behaviour for mental health issues: a systematic review” BMJ Mil Health 2022;168:99-104. Page 1 “Results”.
[9] Victoria Williamson, Neil Greenberg, Sharon Steelink “Perceived stigma and barriers to care in UK Armed Forces personnel and veterans with and without probable mental disorders” BMC Psychology Article 75, Page 2 “Background” (27 November 2019)
[10] Parachute Regiment Charter https://supportourparas.org/wp content/uploads/2015/01/ParachuteRegimentCharter.pdf (02 April 2022)
[11] Parachute Regiment Charter https://supportourparas.org/wp content/uploads/2015/01/ParachuteRegimentCharter.pdf (02 April 2022)
[12] Ministry of Defence “Medical Deployability Standards in UK Armed Forces As At April 2018” (21 December 2018)
[13] NHS Midlands and Lancashire “Guidance for considering the needs of Military Veterans and their families in commissioning health services” (April 2019)
[14] Gov “Veterans seeking support for their mental health” https://www.gov.uk/guidance/veterans-seeking-support-with-physical-health (18 February 2020)
[15] Armed Forces Network “Army Military Abbreviations Acronyms Slang Words” www.sussexarmedforcesnetwork.nhs.uk (Feb 2018)
[16] NHS “Mental health support for veterans, service leavers and reservists” https://www.nhs.uk/nhs-services/armed-forces-community/mental-health/veterans-reservists/ (24 August 2021)





Comments