Free will
Updated: Nov 2
The hardest part of being free, is deciding what to do with it. Because a person could choose to do whatever they want, but it slips down to a binary decision in a non binary world of choices. Do I do good or evil? I often see people that would consider themselves, to be part of my peer group, who have very clearly pivoted into the predictably controversial content for their social media. A particularly slippery slope, I find. The algorithm loves the controversial and even more so, the right wing. All of a sudden, those claiming to be “common sense’ posters, which just means anti intellectualism, which makes the demographic of the angry at the system and poorly educated, love their content, are generating misinformation and are more and more aligning themselves closer hate speech.
But I see their posts and I know some of them personally, I don’t believe for one moment that they aren’t aware of what they are doing or why they do it.
So, why do it?
Well, the pros of doing it, are that you gain social media notoriety really quickly, the likes pour in and everyone comments, mainly really positive, not because it is positive, but because you have been pushed to the right audience by social media. The algorithm loves their controversy, and when thousands of people tell you how brilliant and clever and right you are, that can feel great. That feeling can be addictive.
Am I offering far too much credit to these people, by saying that they know, but don’t care? Maybe they don’t know? Maybe genuinely they think themselves in the right, but if you have had even the most basic exposure to the psycho/socio/biological model of mental health you would at least have an understanding of motivations and would stop making content about “being a lion” on social media and calling people “fat losers”.
And by the way, the psycho/socio/biological model of human behaviour is literally day one stuff. There is no way they don’t know that human beings aren’t as reductionist as their aggressive and controversial social media content suggests them to be.
They’re making a reductionist portrayal of what is quite complicated human behaviour.
But then, is that not what I have just done? I have suggested that they are good or evil, whilst then commenting on the complicated and layered nature of humans? So then, if they are not evil, what are they? Well, to some, the very few, they will think themselves right, that doesn’t make them evil, although if we measure ignorance and evil by outcome, often they are the very same thing.
So then, they’re choosing to do it, but are they choosing out of a desire to be evil, or are they doing so, because it feels good to do it? Because the validation that it gives them, the sense of importance and the belonging to a tribe, does that mean then, that the decision that they are making, is coming from a lack of self awareness?
When you are tired, and you eat the entire bag of the kids sweets, then feel guilty for it, then do the same a few nights later, is that the equivalent psychological process?
So, what’s if they do know, and they do know that they are causing harm but justify it, not because it feels good, but because they think that they’re in the right? This is a distinctly different thing to being evil, surely, because an individual making social media content who has undergone psychological training, but still spreads hate and misinformation, knowing that people are harmed by their content BUT believe themselves to be right. But, believing yourself to be right, that surely means that some form of justification has gone on, and in least in your own head, what you are doing is morally just? Complex isn’t it.
I think about this a lot, if I started making really out of pocket social media content, a real Andrew Tate style character in the void now left by him online, but I thought it was the right thing to do, I wouldn’t be evil, but if I were doing it without knowledge of what I were doing, then I was stupid, but if I did it knowing I was causing harm, but it made me money and got me followers and made me feel good, then maybe, yeah I would be evil. Or at least vulnerable to the absorption of the messages of capitalism and truly lost in morality.
So, what to do with all this free will, if it means a minefield of good vs evil, of examined behaviours and scrutinised thought patterns. And it really does boil down to one very simple sentence, “do unto others, what you would have done to yourself”.
I know, it is that simple. It actually is though, wading through the emotional complexities and nuances and dramas and confusions, literally just think “if someone did this to me, would I like it?”
Don’t muddy the water with emotional interference, scratching around for justifications and assertions as to why it is ok to respond to something the way that I want to, but rather, learn to do things the way that you should do.
Big difference.
Good luck





Comments