A systemic error in thinking, how gender and culture shape the world you believe you see
Updated: Nov 2
A systemic error in thinking – how gender and culture shape the world you believe you see and the issues for those of us, trying to record it.
I am a boy, a white, British, bloke. Roast dinner Sundays and Oasis on blast – my British, emotional castle. I grew up around drug dealers and violence but my view of the world, is by default, still very narrow. I see everything through the lens of what I understand, and like most humans, I reject what I don’t. Like when you walk up the stairs in a block of flats and everyone is cooking different foods that smell horrible until you get to yours? That’s how the world not just smells, but how it also looks to you, and everyone else too. Things that do not align with your cultural understanding of the world are then rejected by you. This is your bias. The brain does it to create norms and expectations, which in turn allow us to create a safe environment which we can survive in. What we expect to see, we want to see and we actively look for it.
Cultural bias exists everywhere and when you have learned to see it, you cannot un-see it. People rejecting what sits outside of their narrow world view, whether that’s dancing or music or art or how a person works or sleeps or grieves or loves or believes themselves to be.
And it isn’t just the culture, who we identify as the shared way of life of a group of people, including values, beliefs, rules and language that we can observe creating the biggest biases and challenge to accurate psychological testing. But gender too. Gender, as in the social roles, behaviours, expressions and norms that a culture associates with being a man, woman or another gender expression.
I have a 5-year-old stepson and he loves monster trucks and smashing things and shouting and jumping and playing. Is it that he does intrinsically like those things? Or is it simply that the adverts on TV show little boys playing like that, and he relates to the boys he sees and therefore does that himself? Or that the toys he picks are aimed towards boys with pictures of boys playing with them on it? Is it that we call pink a “girls colour” it was actually the other way around historically, that blue was feminine and pink the masculine, until the Nazis made homosexuals wear pink triangles, so no, pink is not a “girls” colour but it is an interesting reflection of gender expectations….and bigotry.
The world that boys experience compared to that of women is very different. Firstly, the social conditioning associated to gender, girls are traditionally told to take up less space, to care for others, are given dolls and toy cooking equipment, the entire basis of their play is in the service of others and provision of their needs. Boys are taught to play rough, to fight and be outside to be more egocentric and louder. Those little girls quickly become young women, and the world is a threatening place. All of a sudden, the girl who was conditioned into providing care for everyone, is being called naïve by a callous society when she does that, for a monster in a man’s disguise, and the monster brutalises her. The way in which boys experience the world is fundamentally different to that of women, it is, in many ways safer, although more likely to be victims of violent crime, a woman’s difficulty in defending herself means that she is extremely vulnerable and far more likely to be significantly hurt.
These biases can affect an individual’s perspectives and reasoning when it comes to psychological experimentation, debates and results. It can also lead to different treatment due to gender and not because of the individual’s subjective needs, but rather, by what the stereotype dictates their gender will want to do and how they will behave.
The ever-controversial psychiatrist Freud, went so far as to say that “anatomy is destiny”, arguing that there are genuine psychological differences between men and women, because of their physical differences in biology, he even said that girls viewed femininity as a failed version of masculinity. A line still used by the right-wing grifters, today.
However an in-depth study in 1974 by Maccoby and Jacklin, revealed 4 main differences between boys and girls, these were; girls have a greater verbal ability, boys have greater visual and spatial abilities, boys have greater arithmetical ability and girls are less aggressive than boys. However, this is not true in every case that boys and girls can vary greatly, but that upholding stereotypical assumptions and validating the rampant sexual discrimination that can be observed in modern society, means that every individual must be treated as such.
See the individual, not the cultural or gender bias, just see the human.
There are three types of gender bias; alpha bias, beta bias and androcentrism. Alpha bias is when the differences between men and women are greatly exaggerated and therefore, male and female stereotypes are exaggerated as well. Whatever comes to mind when you hear men talk about “alpha”? This is it, muscularity and height and hyper aggressiveness and traditional gender roles (which actually aren’t that traditional at all as the further back in time you go, the more evidence for an egalitarian you can find).
Beta bias is when the differences between men and women are minimised, this is when findings for men are applied to women, without their consideration. Things such as safety tests, clothing, toilets (the argument being that equality will exist when women don’t have to queue like men do for the toilet)
Lastly, androcentrism; which is the application of male behaviour to the social normative behaviour and regarding the female behaviour as abnormal. So studies into violence, that then labels an entire culture or race as violent or non-violent, but the studies into this only included men and therefore, are not accurate. In psychology, these gender biases must be assessed to any findings, to be sure that the findings are as accurate as possible. Basically, when deciding how a group behave, be sure you’re seeing them as individuals that share values and beliefs and rules, not as just men, with hyper aggressiveness expectations and therefore, biases.
In a similar way to gender differences, there are many differences in cultures that must be considered when trying to accurately produce any psychological findings. Attitudes, behaviours and beliefs are often products of an individual’s surroundings, and many cultures have many different environments.
For example, in United States and Australia, individuals celebrate their individualism, the power of the individual. How they must make money and gain power regardless of the wider implications to their social group, something that I have named the “Bonnie Blue Personal Philosophy” and yes, I know that she is British, but often in the mix of the hyper individuals personal philosophy is a very skewed version of Christianity, so to compare their beliefs to their much hated Bonnie Blue, for me, is a wonderful response. Whilst in Korea, individuals celebrate their connection to others and are defined by their membership to their social group, Yang – Soo Rhee 1981 is well worth a look into their social studies on the behaviours of collectivism.
In conclusion, there are many biases that must be considered, not only is every single individual an individual with their own subjective attitudes, behaviours and beliefs, but groups have their own behaviours, based upon what defines the group, from their gender to their culture no two groups are the same. To assume one better than the other is grossly naïve, to consider the self to be more informed or better equipped to deal with challenge, is again, grossly naïve. We must learn to shrug off the biases that we are holding onto, to refuse to repeat foolishness from our pasts and to see things and people as they are, not as we are.
Stronger, together.
James Elliott
Founder, Think Yourself Resilient
If you would like to talk about coaching or courses with Think Yourself Resilient, contact rachel@thinkyourselfresilient.co.uk





Comments